Driving under the influence (DUI) is a serious offense, but when it results in death or serious injury, the legal consequences are much more severe. This guide covers what happens when a DUI offender is responsible for killing or seriously injuring another person, including legal charges, penalties, defenses, and what victims or their families can do.

---

1. Legal Charges for DUI Offenders Who Cause Death or Serious Injury

A. DUI Manslaughter (If the Victim Dies)

If a person dies due to a DUI-related accident, the driver may face DUI manslaughter charges. The specific charge depends on the circumstances:

• Vehicular Manslaughter – A less severe charge if the death was caused by reckless driving but without extreme negligence.
• Gross Vehicular Manslaughter While Intoxicated – A more severe charge when the driver acted with extreme negligence.
• Second-Degree Murder ("Watson Murder") – If the offender has prior DUIs and was aware of the dangers, they may be charged with second-degree murder (especially in states like California).

B. DUI with Serious Bodily Injury

If a DUI leads to severe injuries but not death, the driver may be charged with:

• Felony DUI Causing Injury – Applies if the injuries are severe, such as paralysis, brain damage, or permanent disability.
• Aggravated DUI – A more serious form of DUI if the victim suffers life-changing injuries.

In many states, this can be charged as a felony, meaning prison time, large fines, and long-term consequences.

---

2. Penalties for DUI Manslaughter or Injury

A. DUI Manslaughter Penalties

Punishments for DUI manslaughter depend on the state but commonly include:

• Prison Sentence – Ranges from 4 to 25+ years, depending on prior offenses and the case details.
• Fines – Can go up to $10,000 or more.
• License Revocation – A permanent or long-term suspension of driving privileges.
• Probation & Parole – Some cases allow parole after serving a portion of the sentence.
• Restitution to Victims – The offender may be ordered to pay financial compensation to the victim's family.

B. DUI with Serious Injury Penalties

For cases involving severe injuries but not death:

• Prison Time – Typically 1 to 15 years depending on severity.
• Fines – Up to $5,000 or more.
• License Suspension – Often several years or permanent revocation.
• Mandatory Alcohol Programs – Some states require long-term DUI education or rehabilitation.

---

3. Factors That Impact the Severity of Charges

Several factors can make the punishment more severe:

• Previous DUI Convictions – A history of DUI offenses leads to harsher penalties.
• High Blood Alcohol Concentration (BAC) – If the BAC is very high (0.15% or more), the charge may be elevated.
• Hit-and-Run – Leaving the scene of the accident increases penalties.
• Reckless Driving – Speeding, ignoring traffic signals, or street racing worsens the case.
• Endangering a Child – If a child was in the vehicle, additional child endangerment charges apply.

---

4. Possible Defenses for DUI Offenders

A DUI offender facing manslaughter or serious injury charges may have legal defenses, but they are difficult to argue. Some common defenses include:

• Challenging the BAC Test – Claiming the breathalyzer or blood test was inaccurate.
• Proving Lack of Negligence – Arguing that the accident was caused by another driver or road conditions.
• Violation of Rights – If law enforcement violated legal procedures, evidence may be dismissed.
• Medical Emergency – In rare cases, proving that the driver suffered a sudden medical emergency (e.g., seizure) may reduce charges.

However, these defenses rarely work in serious DUI cases, especially if there is strong evidence.

---

5. What Victims or Families Can Do

If you or a loved one is a victim of a DUI crash, there are legal steps you can take:

• File a Wrongful Death or Personal Injury Lawsuit – The victim's family can sue the DUI offender for financial compensation.
• Seek Criminal Justice – Work with law enforcement to ensure strict prosecution.
• Advocate for Stricter DUI Laws – Some families start awareness campaigns to prevent future tragedies.

---

6. Final Thoughts: The Life-Changing Impact of DUI Crashes

A DUI offense that kills or injures someone is not just a legal issue—it's a life-altering tragedy for everyone involved. The offender faces serious criminal charges, and the victims and their families endure devastating losses.

The best way to avoid this situation? Never drink and drive. Use a rideshare service, a designated driver, or stay where you are. One bad decision can ruin multiple lives forever.

FAQs

1. What happens if I cause an accident while driving under the influence in California?

If you injure or kill someone while driving under the influence (DUI), you could face felony charges, including DUI with injury, vehicular manslaughter, or even second-degree murder (Watson Murder).

---

2. What is the difference between DUI manslaughter and DUI murder?

• DUI Manslaughter applies when a drunk driver kills someone due to negligence.
• DUI Murder (Watson Murder) applies if the driver had prior DUIs and knew the dangers of drunk driving but chose to drive intoxicated anyway.

---

3. Can a first-time DUI offender be charged with manslaughter?

Yes. Even if it's your first DUI, you can be charged with vehicular manslaughter if you cause someone's death while driving under the influence.

---

4. What are the penalties for DUI manslaughter in California?

• Misdemeanor: Up to one year in county jail.
• Felony: 4 to 10 years in state prison.
• Fines: Up to $10,000.
• License suspension and possible restitution to victims.

---

5. What is Gross Vehicular Manslaughter While Intoxicated?

It's a felony charge when a DUI driver kills someone due to reckless actions, such as speeding or running a red light. This carries 4 to 10 years in state prison.

---

6. What is Watson Murder in a DUI case?

Watson Murder is second-degree murder for DUI offenders who kill someone after previously being convicted of a DUI. It carries a sentence of 15 years to life in prison.

---

7. Can a DUI with serious injury be charged as a felony?

Yes. Under Vehicle Code 23153, DUI causing serious bodily injury can be charged as a felony with up to 16 years in prison.

---

8. Can I be charged with multiple counts if I injure more than one person?

Yes. If multiple people are injured or killed, each victim counts as a separate charge, increasing prison time and penalties.

---

9. Will I lose my driver's license after a DUI manslaughter charge?

Yes. A conviction for DUI manslaughter or DUI causing injury results in a long-term suspension or permanent revocation of your license.

---

10. What if the victim was my passenger?

Even if the injured or deceased person was your own passenger, you can still face felony DUI charges.

---

11. Can I avoid prison time with a plea deal?

Possibly. Your attorney might negotiate a plea deal for reduced charges, but serious DUI cases often result in mandatory prison time.

---

12. Can I be sued in civil court by the victim's family?

Yes. The victim's family can file a wrongful death lawsuit or personal injury lawsuit to recover damages.

---

13. Does having a prior DUI make the penalties worse?

Yes. If you have prior DUI convictions, your sentence will likely be much harsher, and you may face Watson Murder charges.

---

14. What defenses can I use in a DUI manslaughter case?

Possible defenses include:

• The BAC test was inaccurate.
• The accident was not your fault.
• Police misconduct or illegal traffic stops.

However, DUI manslaughter charges are very difficult to fight.

---

15. How long do prosecutors have to file charges against me?

For felony DUI charges, prosecutors have three years to file charges. However, for Watson Murder, there is no statute of limitations.

---

16. Can I get probation instead of prison?

Probation is rare in DUI cases involving death or serious injury. Judges usually impose prison time.

---

17. What happens if I flee the scene after a DUI crash?

Fleeing the scene (hit-and-run) will increase penalties, possibly adding 5 more years to your prison sentence.

---

18. Will my car insurance cover damages if I caused the accident?

Most insurance policies do not cover damages from criminal DUI cases, meaning victims can sue you personally for damages.

---

19. Can I get my record expunged after a DUI manslaughter conviction?

Felony DUI manslaughter cannot be expunged. It stays on your record permanently.

---

20. How can I avoid a DUI manslaughter or serious injury charge?

• Never drink and drive. Use a rideshare app or designated driver.
• If you have prior DUIs, be extra cautious. Watson Murder laws apply if you re-offend.
• Educate others on the dangers of drunk driving to prevent tragedies.